Sheamus McGreedy thinks that by pretending to be a leprechaun he can steal Polly Esther, Woolworth, and the other sheep and make Ian O'Conner's farm his pot of gold. When Patch the Pirate arrives, the message of the true Good Shepherd proves to be the undoing of this unlucky "leprechaun."

Songs include: The Lord's My Shepherd • Whiners • Me, Me, Me • Don't Be Sheepish • Irish Potatoes • Bow the Knee • Ninety and Nine • Walkin' Through the Fire • Sign Me Up • Blarney • Hear My Cry • Shine God's Word • I Just Wanna Be a Sheep